6 major TV characters that were recast after an actor died (2024)

Back to Articles

By: Decades Staff Posted: April 28, 2017

6 major TV characters that were recast after an actor died (1)

How does a TV show react to the death of a star? In some cases, especially in television's early history, the character would simply disappear without a trace or mention. Such was the case with Nana Bryant of Make Room for Daddy and Ward Bond of Wagon Train. Other series opted to write off the characters, having them move away or die offscreen.

However, a few bold shows took another route — recasting the character. This can be especially risky when it comes to fan reaction. Most recently, the Starz series Spartacus replaced its Spartacus after the first season.

We are looking further back. Here are some notable instances of characters being recast after a death in the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s. If you remember these changes, how did you react?

1 6 major TV characters that were recast after an actor died (2)

Hannibal Heyes of 'Alias Smith and Jones'

Modeled after Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, Alias Smith and Jones was a wonderful early-'70s series with humor, grit and guns. The cast was stellar, too, including Sally Field.Pete Duel (pictured here) starred as Hannibal "Honest John Smith" Heyes. On New Year's Eve 1971, the rising TV star committed suicide. The executive producer tactfully wanted to end the series, but the network pushed forward, promoting narratorRoger Davis to the role of H. Heyes.

2 6 major TV characters that were recast after an actor died (3)

Gladys Kravitz of 'Bewitched'

As neighbor Gladys Kravitz, Alice Pearce provided brilliant comic moments on Bewitched, repeatedly dropping her jaw with a befuddled look. Pearce was diagnosed with terminal cancer before Bewitched started in 1964, a fact which the actress hid from producers. Towards the end of the show's second season, Pearce passed away from ovarian cancer. Gladys was recast, with Sandra Gould taking her place. For the show's second season, Pearce posthumously won an Emmy Award for her guest-starring role.

Image: Sony Pictures Television

3 6 major TV characters that were recast after an actor died (4)

Julie Erskine of 'Phyllis'

After a series of guest-starring roles on television in the 1970s, Colby finally got her big break as Julie on the Mary Tyler Moore Show spin-offPhyllis. Unfortunately, after only completing three episodes of the series, Colby was shot and killed in a parking lot by a drive-by shooter. Police concluded the shooting was random, and the killers were never found. On Phyllis, the show had to go on, and Colby was replaced by Liz Torres.

Image: 20th Television

4 6 major TV characters that were recast after an actor died (5)

Beulah of 'The Beulah Show'

Beginning as a radio program, Beulah holds a significant place in history. The story of a housekeeper and cook, the series was both the first network radio program and the first sitcom to star a black woman. Nevertheless, today it remains largely unseen, due to its woefully dated depictions of African-Americans.Ethel Waters first played the role on the television series beginning in 1950, though she quit after the first season. The production moved from the Bronx to Hollywood, and Hattie McDaniel jumped from the radio version to the TV adaptation.McDaniel fell ill after six episodes and was replaced by screen veteran Louise Beavers. The plan was for McDaniel to return to the role, but she passed away from breast cancer. Her episodes were tacked onto the end of the second season.

Image: ABC

5 6 major TV characters that were recast after an actor died (6)

Ellery Queen of 'The Adventures of Ellery Queen'

The name Ellery Queen is now synonymous with the mystery genre. The iconic name made his television debut on the DuMont network in 1950. After the first season, star Richard Hart suddenly died of a heart attack.Lee Bowman slipped into the role, and remains the far more recognized Ellery, thanks to the series hopping over to the far more successful ABC network.

Image: BJ's Records & Nostalgia / YouTube

6 6 major TV characters that were recast after an actor died (7)

Dick Powell of 'The Dick Powell Show'

If you have a show called The Dick Powell Show, the worst thing that probably could happen is losing Dick Powell. While he is not a "character," the movie veteran hosted his anthology series on NBC. Imagine The Twilight Zone without Rod Serling. Midway through its second and final season, Powell sadly succumbed to lung cancer. Some rather famous friends stepped in to host the show, which was retitled The Dick Powell Theatre. How famous? How's this for a lineup:Frank Sinatra, Ronald Reagan,Rock Hudson, Milton Berle, Jack Lemmon, Dean Martin, Steve McQueen and John Wayne were just some of the pals who stepped in to help the show.

Image: NBC

6 major TV characters that were recast after an actor died (2024)

FAQs

Why did they change Gladys Kravitz? ›

Gladys Kravitz of 'Bewitched'

Pearce was diagnosed with terminal cancer before Bewitched started in 1964, a fact which the actress hid from producers. Towards the end of the show's second season, Pearce passed away from ovarian cancer. Gladys was recast, with Sandra Gould taking her place.

What happened to spartacus actor? ›

Illness and death

In March 2010, Whitfield was diagnosed with stage IV non-Hodgkin lymphoma and began undergoing treatment immediately in New Zealand. This delayed production of season two of Spartacus: Vengeance.

Why do shows change actors? ›

Various reasons. One of the most common is that an actor gets tired of a role or has health issues. Sometimes it works. More often than not it doesn't.

Why did they recast Darren on Bewitched? ›

Mr. York was replaced on the show by Dick Sargent in 1969 when problems stemming from an old back injury, including overdependence on painkillers, forced him to leave.

Why was Louise Tate replaced on Bewitched? ›

Alice Pearce died unexpectedly of ovarian cancer in 1966. Similar to the way the Darrin switch was handled later, the “new” Gladys (played by Sandra Gould) was never explained. What's more interesting is the fact that the first Louise Tate (Irene Vernon) left Bewitched willingly to pursue a different career.

What was the biggest box office flop of all time? ›

10 Biggest Box Office Bombs of All Time, Ranked
  1. 1 John Carter ($133-236 million)
  2. 2 The Lone Ranger ($186-221 million) ...
  3. 3 The 13th Warrior ($112-210 million) ...
  4. 4 Mortal Engines ($189 million) ...
  5. 5 Cutthroat Island ($187 million) ...
  6. 6 Sinbad: Legend of the Seven Seas ($184 million) ...
  7. 7 Battleship ($177 million) ...
Jan 10, 2023

Why do so many actors whisper? ›

“When you're whispering, you're making a choice to restrain your expressiveness,” Urbaniak said. “This is very much in keeping with an old leading-man tradition of conveying strength through restraint.” John Wayne didn't Talk Like This, but his voice still confined his expressiveness, which made him appear strong.

What seperates a good actor from a great actor? ›

The very best actors have good technique and exceptional talent. Acting techniques, like projecting your voice and movement on stage, can be learned and finessed, improving any talent. The extra edge that extraordinary natural talent brings is something that cannot be taught and is what makes great actors stand out.

Why was Lesley Ann replaced in Spartacus? ›

She originally auditioned for the role of Sura but auditioned for the role of Naevia instead. Brandt did not return due to production delays following the death of Andy Whitfield, and she was replaced by Cynthia Addai-Robinson.

What actor has non Hodgkin's lymphoma? ›

Oscar-winning actor Jane Fonda shared via Instagram that she has been diagnosed with non-Hodgkin lymphoma, a blood cancer that involves the white blood cells of the body.

How old was Spartacus when he died? ›

What was the controversial scene in Bewitched? ›

For the scene in which Samantha casts a spell that makes Mr. Brockway see everyone as having black skin, the white actors, including Sargent and White, appeared in blackface.

Did Esmeralda replace Aunt Clara on Bewitched? ›

Aunt Clara

She has a collection of over 3,000 doorknobs (inspired by Lorne's real-life collection). Rather than recast the role after Marion Lorne died at the end of the fourth season, she was replaced in season six with Samantha's bumbling new housekeeper Esmeralda.

Who was the best Darrin on Bewitched? ›

On the hit 1960s sitcom Bewitched, Dick York played Darrin Stephens, the long-suffering mortal married to witch-turned-housewife, Samantha. Yet in season six of the show's eight-season run, York was replaced in the role by actor Dick Sargent.

Is Aunt Clara Maurice's sister? ›

“fact” that Clara is Maurice's sister and that Maurice, out of great love for his sister, insisted that Endora invite her to join in on the activities she would have with Enchantra and Hagatha.

Was Jim Carrey in Bewitched? ›

Jim Carrey was approached to play Jack Wyatt/Darrin Stephens, but had to decline because of other commitments. As he resembles Dick York, it was commonly felt that he would be the only good choice for the role (and that anyone like Will Ferrell would just be miscast).

What was Endora's last name on Bewitched? ›

For Endora as a child on Halloween, see Young Endora. Endora is Samantha Stephens' mother and Maurice's wife.
...
Episodes.
EpisodeAirdate
Remember the MainMay 20, 1965
Eat at Mario'sMay 27, 1965
Cousin EdgarJune 3, 1965
Alias Darrin StephensSeptember 18, 1965
143 more rows

What movie only made $20 dollars? ›

Zyzzyx Road
Theatrical release poster
Directed byJohn Penney
Written byJohn Penney
Produced byJohn Penney
12 more rows

Which Disney movie lost the most money? ›

Disney's Strange World to Lose $100 Million: Why It Flopped at Box Office - Variety.

What movie has a 1 billion dollar budget? ›

The Rise of Skywalker was the last movie to gross over $1 billion before the COVID-19 pandemic, but fan reception to the grand finale of the Star Wars Skywalker saga continues to be mixed.

How do famous actors cry? ›

The Menthol Method Here's a trick frequently used when professional actors make themselves cry. Menthol tear sticks and menthol tear-producing sprays are products designed specifically to generate tears and are often used by film and TV actors.

How do actors get their voice so deep? ›

Read passages from your favorite book aloud, aiming to create and keep a lower timbre. Hum deep in your throat to warm up your voice in a deeper register. Create a buzzing noise with your lips, deescalating in pitch until you can comfortably create lower notes. Don't force it, but try to gently expand your range.

Can actors cry on the spot? ›

If you are like most human beings, you have probably had a good cry—maybe while watching a sad movie or maybe after a break-up. Of course, some tears are produced because of extreme grief or pain, and sometimes we cry when we experience profound moments of joy. Actors can recall these memories and produce "real" tears.

Who is the best actor in the world? ›

Empire's 50 Greatest Actors Of All Time List, Revealed
  • Denzel Washington. ...
  • Tom Hanks. ...
  • Marilyn Monroe. ...
  • Robert De Niro. ...
  • Bette Davis. ...
  • Natalie Portman. ...
  • Heath Ledger. ...
  • Katharine Hepburn.
Dec 20, 2022

What should you not say to an actor? ›

Things that don't help
  • Saying Nothing. Actors love notes, even if that note is something small. ...
  • Vague Feedback. When you are giving those notes, don't be too vague or cryptic. ...
  • “What's with your Face?” ( Unconstructive criticism) ...
  • Bad attitude.
Jul 23, 2020

Who is the best actor alive today? ›

The 10 Best Male Actors Working Today, According to Ranker
  • Gary Oldman. ...
  • Samuel L. ...
  • Brad Pitt. ...
  • Denzel Washington. ...
  • Robert Downey Jr. ...
  • Johnny Depp. ...
  • Morgan Freeman. ...
  • Leonardo DiCaprio.
Jun 22, 2022

How many actresses played Mrs Kravitz on Bewitched? ›

Their lives are complicated by Samantha's tampering, mortal-hating mother, Endora (Agnes Moorehead); a nosy neighbour, Gladys Kravitz (Alice Pearce, 1964–66; Sandra Gould, 1966–71); and Darrin's demanding boss, Larry Tate (David White).

Who played the second Gladys Kravitz on Bewitched? ›

Sandra Gould (July 23, 1916 – July 20, 1999) was an American actress, perhaps best known for her role as Gladys Kravitz on the sitcom Bewitched. Gould was the second actress to portray the role, debuting at the start of the third season. Brooklyn, New York, U.S.

How many different Mrs Kravitz were on Bewitched? ›

Alice Pearce accepted the role of the Stephens' nosy neighbor soon after discovering that she had terminal cancer. Pearce kept this secret from the "Bewitched" cast and crew and managed to work through 30 episodes before her death in 1966. Sandra Gould took over the role for the remainder of the show's run.

Who played the first Gladys Kravitz on Bewitched? ›

Alice Pearce

What controversial ended Bewitched? ›

Sisters at Heart
"Sisters at Heart"
Bewitched episode
Lisa (left) and Tabitha (right); shown after Tabitha has cast an awry spell to mix both girls' race in response to bigotry endured by other children
Episode no.Season 7 Episode 13
Directed byWilliam Asher
11 more rows

What ended the show Bewitched? ›

Did they change Louise on Bewitched? ›

Louise Tate (Irene Vernon, and, after Vernon's departure from the show, Kasey Rogers) is Larry's wife and Samantha's closest mortal friend. Louise Tate was played by Irene Vernon during the first two seasons and then replaced by Kasey Rogers, who wore a short black wig to appear similar to Vernon.

Who played the newborn baby on Bewitched? ›

Multiple infants actresses played Tabitha until the show's creators settled on one actress for the part. First played by Cynthia Black, Tabitha was then performed by two different sets of twins, until choosing Erin Murphy to be a full-time Tabitha.

Who played Phoebe the frog on Bewitched? ›

HAPPY BIRTHDAY, CORRINE CAMACHO! Ms. Camacho played Phoebe the human frog in Season Three's "Nobody But a Frog Knows How to Live."

Is Aunt Clara Endora's sister? ›

In Endora Moves in for a Spell, Endora says she was an only child until Arthur was born, which would imply Clara is not her sister, since she is older than Endora.

Who was the most powerful witch on Bewitched? ›

Endora, who will probably go down in history as the witch who wore the most eye shadow of any witch ever, was the mother of Samantha Stephens, the sorceress in the 1960s and '70s sitcom Bewitched.

Who was the first Samantha on Bewitched? ›

Elizabeth Victoria Montgomery (April 15, 1933 – May 18, 1995) was an American actress whose career spanned five decades in film, stage, and television. She is best remembered for her leading role as the witch Samantha Stephens on the television series Bewitched.

Who played the little black girl on Bewitched? ›

See Erin Murphy, who played Tabitha on “Bewitched” in the '60s and '70s, hit the red carpet at the Family Film Awards.

Who was the little black girl on Bewitched? ›

Erin Margaret Murphy (born June 17, 1964) is an American actress, who is best known for her role as young Tabitha Stephens in the television sitcom Bewitched, in 103 episodes from the show's third season (in 1966) to the last original episode in 1972.
...
Erin Murphy
RelativesDiane Murphy (twin sister)
6 more rows

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 6063

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.